Mr Sammy's Pizza

Enjoy authentic NY-style pizza, stromboli, garlic parm wings, calzones, and more at Mr Sammy's Pizza in Lake Placid, FL. Delicious Italian favorites with fresh ingredients. Call +1 863-699-1219!

Welcome to Mr Sammy's Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Mr Sammy's Pizza
Mr Sammy's Pizza
Mr Sammy's Pizza
Mr Sammy's Pizza

Discover Mr Sammy's Pizza, a treasure tucked away at 312 W Interlake Blvd in beautiful Lake Placid, Florida. This pizza haven serves the community with delicious New York-style pizzas, each prepared to perfection.

Enjoy a diverse menu that includes mouthwatering strombolis, garlic parm wings, and classic Italian dishes like chicken parm and eggplant rollatini. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, every bite promises to transport your taste buds straight to Italy.

With a friendly atmosphere and a dedication to top-notch service, Mr Sammy's Pizza stands out as a local favorite, making it the perfect spot for family dinners, date nights, or casual hangouts with friends. Dive into a slice, and become part of the Mr Sammy's family.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

312 W Interlake Blvd, Lake Placid, FL 33852, United States

Phone

+1 863-699-1219

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Mr Sammy's Pizza
Mr Sammy's Pizza
Mr Sammy's Pizza
Mr Sammy's Pizza

Mr Sammy's Pizza stands as a beloved culinary landmark in Lake Placid. Its rich history and commitment to quality have made it a community staple since opening. The restaurant prides itself on authenticity and flavor, providing diners with the best of Italian cuisine, from classic pizzas to hearty entrees, all inspired by traditional recipes.

Each dish is crafted from fresh ingredients, ensuring that every bite bursts with flavor. The kitchen showcases remarkable expertise, especially in their garlic parm wings and eggplant parmesan, which regularly receive rave reviews from patrons. In addition to dine-in options, the restaurant caters to those who prefer to enjoy their meals at home, offering convenient takeout services.

Mr Sammy's hosts a bustling atmosphere, particularly during peak times—Friday nights at 6 PM sees the restaurant fully packed. To avoid the crowd while still enjoying the delicious food, try visiting during lunch hours on a weekday. Regulars appreciate this local gem for its consistent quality and inviting ambiance. Community events often draw in neighbors, creating a warm, welcoming vibe. The staff is knowledgeable and eager to share recommendations, ensuring a tailored dining experience. Loyal customers contribute to the restaurant’s familial feel, and frequent gatherings here often spark friendships through shared love for good food.

In Mr Sammy's Pizza, you find not just a meal but an experience filled with laughter and good company. Don't forget to grab a slice next time—who knows, it might just become your new favorite spot!

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • SundayClosed
  • MondayClosed
  • Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-8 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday12-7 PM

Mr Sammy's Pizza boasts an extensive menu, featuring 84 delectable options that cater to all cravings. Pizza lovers can choose from 25 unique flavors, including the spicy hot afterburner and the ever-popular pepperoni classic.

Alongside scrumptious pizza, the menu includes a variety of appetizers such as garlic knots and mozzarella sticks—perfect for sharing or indulging solo. For heartier meals, options like lasagna, stuffed shells, and Mr. Sammy's signature dishes offer a satisfying experience.

The restaurant also accommodates families with a dedicated kids' menu, ensuring even the young ones find something they love. With refreshing beverages and desserts like tiramisu and cannoli, every meal at Mr Sammy's Pizza becomes a culinary adventure.

Mr Sammy's Pizza

Mr Sammy's Pizza features an inviting exterior, with vibrant signage that promises delicious meals inside. Located along W Interlake Blvd, the restaurant often greets customers with the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza wafting through the air. The outdoors has an accessible, friendly feel, making it easy to pop in for a quick bite or plan a longer meal with family.

The outdoor seating option offers an relaxed vibe, perfect for enjoying the warm Florida sunshine while savoring flavorful dishes. Whether dining inside or out, the atmosphere remains lively—often buzzing with families, friends, and pizza lovers exchanging laughter and stories over a shared meal.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

This is the spot! If you want that David Portnoy experience-here it is. New York style, great sauce (not salty), tasty cheese(not to much) and the crust has a perfect crunch!! Pepperoni is not super salty or spicy, it was perfect. Great find, please try it. Beer on tap also for those looking for a slice and a brew. Definitely coming back soon to try the other toppings. Top 3 for sure 9.3 for me. Great service from the staff. Thank you!! Don't sleep on this one. Wow!

R
Ric G.

We had such a wonderful experience! Our kids got to make their own pizzas, and got signed aprons. The experience was wonderful! I had a salad and it was delicious! All the staff were so friendly and attentive! Such a great family friendly experience in Lake Placid, a real gem!

M
McCall A.

We just moved to Lake Placid and went out to find dinner after a long day of moving Well we found our new favorite place ! Great pizza YUM great salad and breadsticks YUM ! Great service (wish I could remember her name) but super sweet nice atmosphere Just a good experience Our new go to spot ! :)

S
Soup10

Awesome people, great menu of delicious items, super cozy environment, ny style is an understatement for this great spot, it is New York pizza, safe to say that it'll be my go to spot for Italian cuisine!!

S
Smiffun W.

Came across Sammy's while house hunting in the area. Amazing NY Pizza. Great crunch and delicious sauce. Canoli was amazing. Loved the welcoming atmosphere and family spirit. My kind of people!!! Must stop if your any where close!

R
Rob M.

I'll be living in Lake Placid on August 1, 2025. I was there to get a place to live this past weekend and received a word-of-mouth advertisement for this place. It lived up to the hype and my expectations!! I had the baked Zitti, it came with a side of meatballs. Delicious!!

R
Rodney W.